Possibilities and limitations of bankruptcy prediction models applied in preventing insolvency

The paper provides the solution to the problem of an integrated classification of existing bankruptcy prediction based on the content analysis of 270 relevant foreign and Russian publications issued within a period of 1910—2020. The author identifies two main groups of models— normative and positive, with the latter categorized into expert, mixed and objective including traditional statistical models and artificial intelligent techniques; and considers the specific features of certain predicting models, their advantages and disadvantages. He then reveals the economic content of such models and the set of ratios applied for identifying company's financial distress with the following conclusions: approaches to the variables selection are rarely justified, indicators are usually borrowed from previous models or generated automatically by the database configuration; the accounting approach to bankruptcy forecasting based on financial ratios prevails and has serious limitations for Russian companies; the most significant market, value and qualitative variables indicating a decline in the business financial stability are highlighted. Significant limitations of the general use of bankruptcy prediction models for making decisions aimed at insolvency prevention are identified: the inability to anticipate the impact of informal factors that are irregular, unable to extrapolate, and affect companies in different ways; the need to take into account the economic conditions of the national economy, financial reporting standards, and the level of availability of diverse data; the impossibility of creating a universal indicative basis to identify decline of sustainability of any business due to the high volatility of operating conditions in Russia. Bayesian methods and nowcasting, as well as the development of forecasting models for certain industries, are promising areas for the development of modern approaches to bankruptcy prediction, but the fundamental activity for preventing insolvency is not forecasting by models, but the implementation of continuous monitoring of the overall business performance in relation to influencing market, operational, investment, financial, managerial and organizational factors, taking into account significant qualitative variables.

1. Arinichev, I. V., Matveeva, L. G., & Arinicheva, I. V. (2018). Forecasting the bankruptcy of an organization based on metric methods of data mining. Economic Regulation Issues, 9(1), 62-73. https://doi.org/10.17835/2078-5429.2018.9.1.061-073

2. Bobyleva, A. Z., & Lvova, O. A. (2019a). Management of transformational programs of mergers and acquisitions of distressed companies. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Management, 18(4), 483-509. https://doi.org/10.21638/11701/spbu08.2019.401

3. Bobyleva, A. Z., & Lvova, O. A. (2019b). Bankruptcy prevention: institutional support of mergers and acquisitions of distressed companies. Problemy teorii i praktiki upravleniya (6), 100-112.

4. Gorbatkov, S. A., Beloliptsev, I. I., & Makeeva, E. Yu. (2013). Choosing a system of economic indicators for diagnosing and predicting bankruptcies based on the neural network Bayesian approach, Finance: Theory and Practice, 4, 50-61.

5. Makeeva, E. Yu., & Arshavsky, I. V. (2014). Application of neural networks and semantic analysis for bankruptcy forecasting. Corporate Finance, 8(4), 130-140.

6. Makushina, E. Yu., & Shikhlyarova, I. A. (2018). Modeling the probability of bankruptcy of Russian non-financial companies. Finance and Credit, 24(2), 95-110. https://doi.org/10.24891/fc.24.1.95

7. Mogilat, A. N. (2019). Modeling the financial stability of companies in the real sector (on the example of industry). (PhD Thesis). Moscow.

8. Pestova, A. A., & Mamonov, M. E. (2016). A survey of methods for macroeconomic forecasting:looking for perspective directions in russia. Voprosy Ekonomiki, 6, 45-75. https://doi.org/10.32609/0042-8736-2016-6-45-75

9. Puganovskaya, T. I., & Galyamin, A. V. (2008). Analysis of foreign research in the field of modeling the bankruptcy of the company. Problems of regional economy, 3, 46-61.

10. Slabinskaya, I. A., & Kravchenko, L. N. (2017). Bankruptcy forecasting as a method of assessing the economic security of organizations. Bulletin of the Belgorod State Technological University named after V. G. Shukhov, 8, 195-199. https://doi.org/10.12737/article_5968b453283fe8.39704252

11. Stankevich, I. P. (2020). Comparison of the methods of sciencasting of macroeconomic indicators on the example of Russian GDP. Applied Econometrics, 59, 113-127.

12. Khaidarshina, G. A. (2007). Quantitative methods for assessing the risk of bankruptcy of enterprises: classification and practical application. Finance: Theory and Practice, 4, 169-178.