New facts on academic quality and formats of Economic Faculty Final Papers

This is the first publication in a series of the three papers that present the research findings of the diagnostic project on the quality of Bachelors’ final papers initiated by the Faculty of Economics Pedagogical committee in 2021. We present the findings of academic quality analysis and the typology of the main formats of Bachelors’ final papers. The research is based on a methodology that is specially developed along the lines of positive economics approach. Its application allows us to demonstrate the qualitative features of the body of final papers prepared by our graduates which include inter alia quality of literature review, research statement, tools of analysis and interpretation of findings. We offer the steps for further strengthening the analytical quality of final papers, including early submission of research hypothesis, elective courses on the methods of academic research and research seminars for undergraduates. We also present a typology of formats for final papers covering Economics and Management streams of study. Based on our positive analysis, we have identified six primary formats of Bachelors’ final papers, which can be combined into three more general categories: academic, project and research, and applied project formats. A comparative analysis of formats in economics and management papers confirms the applicability of common criteria for evaluating and grading the papers, alongside common guidelines for final paper preparation. The study proves the viability of diverse analytical methods while preparing final papers in both streams of study.

1. Aleskerov F. (May 28th 2013) How to prepare and write a thesis paper? Postnauka, accessed on 26.01.2022 https://postnauka.ru/longreads/12747

2. Booth W.C., Colomb G.G., Williams J.M. (2007). The craft of research / Translated by A. Stanislavsky. Moscow: Flinta : Nauka, 360 p.

3. Volkov Yu.G. (2017). Thesis paper: preparation, defense, formatting: practical aid. Mosocw: KNORUS, 218 p.

4. Libman A. (2007). Modern Economic Theory: The Main Tendencies. Voprosy Ekonomiki. 3, 35-54. https://doi.org/10.32609/0042-8736-2007-3-35-54

5. Panarin S.A. (ed.) (2012). How to write a scientific text: the experience of the Young Author’s School: a teaching aid / N.A. Didkovskaya, V.I. Dyatlov, N.V. Lipatova, S.A. Panarin. Irkutsk: "Ottisk", 240 p.

6. Radaev V.V. (2011). How to write an academic text. Educational Studies, 1, 271–293

7. Rayzberg B.A. (2010). Thesis and Degree: Application Guide. Mosocw: INFRA-M, 240 p.

8. Smirnov S. (2015). My research work. How to write a paper, a course paper, a final paper and a research paper (and quote and cite sources). Moscow, 60 p.

9. Eco U. (2003). How to Write a Thesis. Humanitarian sciences: guidance manual / Translated by Ye. Kostyukovich. Moscow: Knizhniy dom “Universitet”, 240 p.